Charitocracy rides off into the sunset

Charitocracy rides off into the sunset
Turns out they were waving goodbye this whole time!

2023 is the final season of Charitocracy! There are 12 monthly pots yet to grant. Let's make them count!

I'll try to keep the sentimentality out of it for now, given there's still almost a whole year left to go. This decision comes after weeks of personal contemplation over the holidays and discussion with Jessica and the rest of our board of directors. It wasn't an easy decision. Charitocracy has been a huge part of my identity for the past 7+ years! But I think it's the right decision for me right now.

I'll cover the How first, then the Why. But feel free to follow up with me directly if you have more questions. I remain an open book, and ever at your service. ❤️

How

  • New donations, sign-ups, gift purchases, etc. are now disabled. We're going out on top with over 400 donors across Charitocracy USA and OBX!
  • All recurring donations after January 31 will be automatically cancelled. No action is required on your part. This way every donor gets at least the 12 months of grant voting they bargained for!
  • Current donors are encouraged to continue voting on through the last vote on New Year's Eve Halloween 2023. Even if your Charitocracy anniversary, the day your annual donation would ordinarily be collected, comes mid-year, you won't suddenly lose your voting privileges.
  • Charitocracy's remaining cash reserves will be distributed into 2023's 12 monthly USA & OBX grant pots. Each successive pot will be bigger than the previous one as we gain more confidence we can meet our final expenses with smaller cash reserves. Our final "season" of grants should be bigger than ever as we "zero out" our remaining funds!

Why

  • There's been angst surrounding some of the more polarizing nominees at Charitocracy USA. For some folks, Charitocracy hasn't represented a positive force in their lives lately, either because they don't agree with the winners or due to some negative interactions online. Believe me, I can relate! And that goes for causes across the political spectrum, both ones that have and have not yet won a monthly grant. I never wanted to create something that could hurt people or cause hard feelings, so that aspect has been a bummer.
  • Meanwhile, I've spent more time than ever in the past few months fighting hackers. Rest assured, Charitocracy has never been breached, nor do we store any of your credit card information in the first place. (Our credit card processor, Stripe, takes care of that.) But what the hackers do like to do, for whatever reason, is to attack web sites and try to knock them offline. On several occasions I've had to interrupt trips or family time to literally fight bot armies (thousands of hijacked computers) flooding Charitocracy from all corners of the world with traffic, known as DDOS: Distributed Denial of Service. And the other thing they like to do is test lists of stolen credit cards by attempting to make donations from them. They automate it so I'll suddenly start getting a donation attempt every 5 seconds. Usually Stripe's fraud detection flags their attempts and reject them, but occasionally some get through. Then I have to refund the donations and eat the credit card processing fees. It's a nice adrenalin rush when it happens, but never a good time.
  • Finally, and perhaps most critically, is that I don't see a clear future for Charitocracy. The prospect of setting up Charitocracy's own endowment fund really brought into focus the fact that if I get hit by a bus, there's no one to take over, and there's no one to even gracefully shut it down. So it would be irresponsible to try to raise money for an uncertain future. While I've always run Charitocracy as lean as possible, with pride in our low overhead, the truth is that my volunteered skill set is actually a bit expensive... to replace. Not to mention I'm effectively on-call 24/7 for years on end with no good way to share that responsibility.

So let's go out there and make Charitocracy's 7th full year not only our last, but also our best! Thank you for the privilege it has been to pool your resources and make a difference in the world. I've had a blast!

Sunset through a Heart
Both images above generated via artificial intelligence using DiffusionBee on Mac. Fun!

9 thoughts on “Charitocracy rides off into the sunset”

  1. What a shame. Your noble intentions and steadfast work deserve accolades from our OBX community. It’s a significant loss.

  2. Sigh. Disappointed but T-totally understandable. The “why” you posted is, unfortunately, sign of the times these days. Regardless, you guys did GREAT. You had a dream, lived it, and…made a difference! Helped a lot of people. Proud of you.

  3. The Community Care Clinic of Dare was one of your last recipients and we were grateful for the community support. I am sorry that this fantastic effort of giving back has given so much angst.
    Good people always come back! Thank you and good luck in your future endeavors.

  4. Much love to you as you made this hard decision. Thanks for all you did to bring awareness to donating for the good of doing it, and helping teach others how a little from a lot of folks really makes a difference! Look at all the time you will have to travel now 🙂

  5. Benj,

    Great work raising the spirit and energy of supporting efforts for good in the Outer Banks… it’s unfortunate that circumstances cause you to end after 2023…

  6. Wow, lots of lessons learned! Goodbyes are always painful but look at what experience you are taking with you to your next adventure! Hmm, maybe take a good and well deserved rest first!

  7. Benj,

    Thank You!
    What you invested yourself in was of tremendous benefit to the community, and your presence will be sorely missed. There are far too few who are willing to make the commitment, and way too many who don’t understand that selfish or polarizing energy is crippling. That’s unfortunate, considering what your cause and vision represent. I checked-in to increase my monthly donation, and I’m a little bummed that I can’t. Please know that the impact Charitocracy had was significant for everyone that it reached. My thanks.

Comments are closed.